Problems of Social Hygiene, Public Health and History of MedicineProblems of Social Hygiene, Public Health and History of Medicine0869-866X2412-2106Joint-Stock Company Chicot154610.32687/0869-866X-2024-32-5-969-978НеопределенThe effect of value orientations of physicians on satisfaction of patients with medical care quality in conditions of uncertaintyTsaranovK NTsaranovKN@mos.ruMarkovD IDIMarkov1998@yandex.ruKomolovaO AKomolovaOA@edu.mos.ruNauruzovaM Amarusya_nauruzova@mail.ruPlutnickyA Nplutnitsky@gmail.comTarbastaevA GAG@Tarbastaev.ruThe State Autonomous Educational Institution of Higher Education “The Moscow Municipal University of Management” of the Moscow Government, 107045, Moscow, RussiaThe Medical Biological University of Innovations and Post-Graduate Education of the Federal State Budget Institution “The A. I. Burnazyan State Research Center of the Russian Federation — Federal Medical Biophysical Center” of The Federal Medical Biological Agency of Russia, 123098, Moscow, RussiaThe State Budget Institution “The Research Institute of Health Care Organization and Medical Management” of the Health Care Department of the city of Moscow, 115088, Moscow, Russia271020243252704202527042025Copyright © 2025,2025<p>The COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic significantly impacted processes of medical care support and medical personnel and managers. The article presents analysis of results of three-year (20192022) studying level of loyalty of legal representatives of patients of one of Moscow children polyclinics. The study covered both legal representatives of patients (more than 190,000 assessments collected over entire observation period) and randomly selected district pediatricians (n=31). It is established that value-intentional consistency of district pediatricians (ratio between individual priorities of medical specialist and his ideas about proper behavior e.g. general medical or corporate values and norms), i.e. degree of interpersonal conflict, significantly affects loyalty of patients to them during uncertainty phase that covered first months of coronavirus pandemic. The physicians with moderate level of consistency between individual priorities and normative ideals demonstrated higher rates of loyalty on part of patients as compared with specialists who had value-intentional inconsistency. It is concluded that in order to increase and maintain this indicator, regular monitoring of social psychological status of medical workers, their material and non-material support and stimulation, development of mentoring system in medical organization and training of medical managers to use social psychological tools for building favorable corporate climate and culture of relations between employees of medical organization and patients are necessary.</p>patient orientationCOVID-19 pandemicvalue orientationshealth care organizationpatient loyaltyprofessional burnoutmedical personnelпациентоориентированностьпандемия COVID-19ценностные ориентацииорганизация здравоохранениялояльность пациентовпрофессиональное выгорание медицинских кадров1.Surkova T. A. Approaches to the concept of patient orientation. Forum molodyh uchenyh = Forum of Young Scientists. 2020;10(50):594–601 (in Russian).2.Federal Law No. 323-FZ of 11/21/2011 (as amended on 07/22/2021) “On the basics of protecting the health of citizens in the Russian Federation” (with amendments and additions, intro. effective from 01.10.2021). Available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_121895/aa2b51003ea5338063d96d38b8a655605311b46e (accessed 1 Dec 2023).3.Yarasheva A. V., Markov D. I. Development of corporate culture of employees of medical organizations. Narodonaselenie = Population. 2022;25(1)155–66. doi: 10.19181/population.2022.25.1.13. EDN OTZEEV (in Russian).4.Markov D. I. Export of medical services: how to increase the competitiveness of Russian healthcare organizations. Zdorov'e megapolisa = The health of the metropolis. 2021;2(2):6–14. doi: 10.47619/2713-2617.zm.2021.v.2i2;6-14. EDN OZAMCH (in Russian).5.Gavrilenko L. S., Chupina V. B. Preparation of future doctors for professional activity in conditions of uncertainty. Azimut nauchnyh issledovanij: pedagogika i psihologija = Azimuth of scientific research: Pedagogy and psychology. 2021;3(36). Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/podgotovka-buduschih-vrachey-k-professionalnoy-deyatelnosti-v-usloviyah-neopredelennosti (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).6.Aksenova E. I., Alexandrova O. A., Yarasheva A. V., Markov D. I. Corporate culture in a medical organization: taking into account the ethnoconfessional affiliation of patients. Problemy social'noj gigieny, zdravoohranenija i istorii mediciny = Problems of social hygiene, health care and the history of medicine. 2022;30(S):943–8. doi: 10.32687/0869-866X-2022-30- s1-943-948. EDN JRMXYS (in Russian).7.Tsaranov K. N. New approaches to assessing the degree of interpersonal interaction in doctor-patient pairs. In: Actual problems of theory and practice of psychological, psychological-pedagogical, pedagogical and linguodidactic research: materials of the international scientific and practical conference, Mytishchi, April 13–14, 2022 [Aktual'nye problemy teorii i praktiki psihologicheskih, psihologo-pedagogicheskih, pedagogicheskih i lingvodidakticheskih issledovanij: materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii, Mytishhi, 13–14 aprelja 2022 goda]. Moscow: Moscow State Regional University; 2022. P. 638–43. EDN BVERSS (in Russian).8.Tsaranov K. N., Tarbastaev A. G. The values of the staff of a medical organization as a factor in the quality of services to patients. In: Psychology of professional activity: problems, current state and prospects of development : materials of the III All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference, Mytishchi, March 05, 2021 [Psihologija professional'noj dejatel'nosti: problemy, sovremennoe sostojanie i perspektivy razvitija : materialy III Vserossijskoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii, Mytishhi, 05 marta 2021 goda]. Moscow: Moscow State Regional University, 2021. P. 93–7. EDN VHCXNS (in Russian).9.Petrikov S. S., Tsaranov K. N., Zavaliy L. B., et al. The intentional potential of scientific and clinical leaders as a strategic resource of a medical organization. Menedzher zdravoohranenija = Health care manager. 2022;(9):40–50. doi: 10.21045/1811-0185-2022-9-40-50. EDN IESWAK (in Russian).10.Golyanich V. M., Bondaruk A. F., Glazyrin A. A. Value contradictions as psychodiagnostic criteria of intentional competence. Upravlencheskoe konsul'tirovanie = Management consulting. 2013;11(59). Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/tsennostnye-protivorechiya-kak-psihodiagnostcheskie-kriterii-intentsionalnoy-kompetentnosti (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).11.Schwartz S. H. Universals in the content and structure of values: Theoretical advances and empirical tests in 20 countries. In: Zanna M. P. (ed.). Advances in experimental social psychology. New York: Academic Press; 1992. Ch. 25. P. 1–65.12.Schwartz S. H. Basic human values: Theory, Measurement, and Applications. Rev. Fr. Sociol. 2006;47(4):929–68.13.Reichheld, Frederick F. “The One Number You Need to Grow”. Harvard Business Review. 2003;81(12):46–54.14.Suroegina A. Yu., Kholmogorova A. B. Professional burnout of medical workers before, during and after the pandemic. Sovremennaja zarubezhnaja psihologija = Modern foreign psychology. 2023;12(2):64–73. doi: 10.17759/jmfp.2023120206 (in Russian).15.Alexandrova O. A., Yarasheva A. V., Alikperova N. V., Vinogradova K. V., Aksenova E. I. Ways to increase the labor motivation of employees of medical organizations. Problemy social'noj gigieny, zdravoohranenija i istorii mediciny = Problems of social hygiene, health care and the history of medicine. 2020;28(S2):1049–55 (in Russian).16.Alikperova N. V., Yarasheva A. V., Vinogradova K. V. Factors of formation of career trajectories of medical workers in Russia. Gumanitarnye nauki. Vestnik Finansovogo universiteta = Humanities. Bulletin of the Financial University. 2020;10(6):81–92. Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/faktory-formirovaniya-kariernyh-traektoriy-meditsinskih-rabotnikov-v-rossii (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).17.Alexandrova O. A., Nenakhova Y. S. Payment and working conditions of Moscow doctors: symptoms of latent problems. In: Sociology of Health: on the way to patient orientation: Materials of the forum, Moscow, November 12, 2019 [Sociologija zdorov'ja: na puti k pacientoorientirovannosti: Materialy foruma, Moskva, 12 nojabrja 2019 goda]. Moscow: The State Budgetary Institution of the city of Moscow “Scientific Research Institute of Health Organization and Medical Management of the Department of Health of the City of Moscow”; 2019. P. 10–2. EDN JHRYGI (in Russian).18.Kholmogorova A. B., Petrikov S. S., Suroegina A. Yu., et al. Occupational burnout and its factors in medical workers involved in providing care to COVID-19 patients at different stages of the pandemic. Neotlozhnaja medicinskaja pomoshh'. Zhurnal im. N. V. Sklifosovskogo = Emergency medical care. The journal named after N. V. Sklifosovsky. 2020;9(3):321–37. doi: 10.23934/2223-9022-2020-9-3-321-337. EDN IENSCL (in Russian).19.Aksenova E. I., Alexandrova O. A., Alikperova N. V., et al. Development of the human resources potential of the capital's healthcare [Razvitie kadrovogo potenciala stolichnogo zdravoohranenija]. Moscow: The State Budgetary Institution of the city of Moscow “Scientific Research Institute of Health Organization and Medical Management of the Department of Health of the City of Moscow”; 2019. 244 p. ISBN 978-5-907251-15-1. EDN DVHZTQ (in Russian).20.Tsaranov K. N., Tarbastaev A. G., Markov D. I., Komolova O. A. Dynamics of patient representatives' loyalty before and during the COVID-19 epidemic on the example of the Moscow children's polyclinic. Menedzher zdravoohranenija = Health care manager. 2022;(7):16–25. doi: 10.21045/1811-0185-2022-7-16-25. EDN EDZTPY (in Russian).21.Aksenova E. I., Gorbatov S. Yu., Kamynina N. N., et al. The impact of coronavirus on accelerating the introduction and use of digital technologies, including telemedicine: In partnership with the World Bank: a Russian report [Vlijanie koronavirusa na uskorenie vnedrenija i ispol'zovanija cifrovyh tehnologij, v tom chisle telemediciny: V partnerstve so Vsemirnym bankom: rossijskij otchet]. Moscow: State Budgetary Institution of the city of Moscow “Scientific Research Institute of Health Organization and Medical Management of the Department of Health of the City of Moscow”; 2022. 95 p. ISBN 978-5-907404-90-8. EDN BGZHKG (in Russian).22.Alexandrova O. A., Kroshilin S. V. Aspects of telemedicine development: historical trends. In: Proceedings of the Scientific Research Institute of Healthcare Organization and Medical Management: A collection of scientific papers [Trudy nauchno-issledovatel'skogo instituta organizacii zdravoohranenija i medicinskogo menedzhmenta: Sbornik nauchnyh trudov]. Issue 2 (12). Moscow: State Budgetary Institution of the city of Moscow “Scientific Research Institute of Health Organization and Medical Management of the Department of Health of the City of Moscow”; 2022. P. 121–32. EDN IRKZRB (in Russian).23.Medvedeva E. I., Kroshilin S. V. New medical technologies: gender differences in the perception of telemedicine. Bjulleten' Nacional'nogo nauchno-issledovatel'skogo instituta obshhestvennogo zdorov'ja imeni N. A. Semashko = Bulletin of the N. A. Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health. 2023;(3):79–86. doi: 10.25742/NRIPH.2023.03.013. EDN GLGIQC (in Russian).24.Raymond M. The trend forecaster's handbook. Hachette UK; 2019.25.Tsaranov K. N., Markov D. I., Komolova O. A., et al. Patient loyalty during the coronavirus period: research experience in the metropolitan children's polyclinic. Problemy social'noj gigieny, zdravoohranenija i istorii mediciny = Problems of social hygiene, health care and the history of medicine. 2023;31(3):334–41. doi: 10.32687/0869-866X-2023-31-3-334-341. EDN KTFZVH (in Russian).26.Yezhova E. N., Kaftandzhiev H. N. Heroes-doctors at the front of the fight against COVID-19: communicative strategies for image positioning. In: Russian Public Relations: trends and drivers: A collection of scientific papers in honor of Professor A. D. Krivonosov [Rossijskaja piarologija: trendy i drajvery: Sbornik nauchnyh trudov v chest' professora A. D. Krivonosova]. Edited by E. Y. Karmalova, K. V. Kiuru. Issue 10. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg State University of Economics; 2021. P. 45–54. EDN QULEYJ (in Russian).27.“Is the coronavirus coming back?”. VCIOM (Russian Public Opinion Research Center). Available at: https://wciom.ru/analytical-reviews/analiticheskii-obzor/koronavirus-vozvrashchaetsja (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).28.Komolova O. A., Tsaranov K. N., Markov D. I. The attitude of Russians towards doctors during the coronavirus period: dynamics of public opinion as a new challenge for Russian healthcare. In: Incomes, expenses and savings of the Russian population: trends and prospects: proceedings of the VIII International Scientific and Practical Conference, Moscow, November 29, 2022 [Dohody, rashody i sberezhenija naselenija Rossii: tendencii i perspektivy: materialy VIII Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii, Moskva, 29 nojabrja 2022 goda]. Rimashevskaya Institute of Socio-Economic Problems of Population of the Federal Research Sociological Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Moscow: Institute of Socio-Economic Problems of Population of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 2023. P. 89–96. EDN CRHJXQ (in Russian).29.Aubusson K. The doctors sleeping under desks because they’re too tired to drive. The Sydney Morning Herald. 26 September 2022. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/national/nsw/the-doctors-sleeping-under-desks-because-they-re-too-tired-to-drive-20220922-p5bk5i.html (accessed 1 Dec 2023).30.Shanafelt T. D., West C. P., Sinsky C., Trockel M., Tutty M., Wang H., Carlasare L. E., Dyrbye L. N. Changes in burnout and satisfaction with work-life integration in physicians and the general US working population between 2011 and 2020. mayo clin. proc. 2022;97(3):491–506. doi: 10.1016/j.mayocp.2021.11.02131.Tsaranov K. N., Tarbastaev A. G., Rakhmatullin R. E. Adaptation and initial testing of the Russian version of the questionnaire “Attitude to safety” for medical organizations. Menedzher zdravoohranenija = Health care manager. 2022;(2):57–64. doi: 10.21045/1811-0185-2022-2-57-64. EDN GUIDUZ (in Russian).32.Schwartz Sh., Butenko T. P., Sedova D. S., Lipatova A. S. The refined theory of basic individual values: application in Russia. Psihologija. Zhurnal Vysshej Shkoly Jekonomiki = Psychology. Psychology. Journal of the Higher School of Economics. 2012;(2). Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/utochnennaya-teoriya-bazovyh-individualnyh-tsennostey-primenenie-v-rossii (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).33.Taranik M. B., Murtazina G. I., Tyurina K. V. Patients on edge in the epidemic season, how to extinguish conflicts and make the clinic patient-oriented. Zdravoohranenie Jugry: opyt i innovacii = Ugra healthcare: experience and innovations. 2021;(1). Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/patsienty-na-vzvode-v-epidsezon-kak-pogasit-konflikty-i-sdelat-kliniku-patsientoorientirovannoy (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).34.Medvedeva E. I., Kroshilin S. V. Non-physicians in medicine: the experience of Moscow. Moskovskaja medicina = Moscow medicine. 2023;4(56):52–62. EDN IWFSTD (in Russian).35.The development of mentoring in the capital's healthcare: new approaches and opportunities: monograph [Razvitie nastavnichestva v stolichnom zdravoohranenii: novye podhody i vozmozhnosti: monografija]. Ed. by E. I. Aksenova; scientific ed. by Y. V. Burdastova. Moscow: GBU “NIIOZMM DZM”; 2023. 145 p. ISBN 978-5-907717-54-1. Available at: https://niioz.ru/moskovskaya-meditsina/izdaniya-nii/monografii/ (accessed 1 Dec 2023) (in Russian).36.Burdastova Yu. V., Nenakhova Yu. S., Alikperova N. V., Markov D. I. New models of mentoring in healthcare as a way to improve the professional competencies of medical workers. Jekonomika. Nalogi. Pravo = Economy. Taxes. Right. 2022;15(3):69–79. doi: 10.26794/1999-849X-2022-15-3-69-79. EDN DGQTHQ (in Russian).37.Mentoring in healthcare: in-demand models. Methodological recommendations [Nastavnichestvo v zdravoohranenii: vostrebovannye modeli. Metodicheskie rekomendacii]. Moscow; 2022. 25 p. (in Russian).38.Alexandrova O. A., Alikperova N. V., Burdastova Yu. V., Vinogradova K. V., Nenakhova Yu. S., Yarasheva A. V. Atlas of the best Russian mentoring practices in the field of healthcare [Atlas luchshih rossijskih praktik nastavnichestva v sfere zdravoohranenija]. Moscow; 2020. 40 p. (in Russian).39.Yarasheva A. V. Reproduction of labor resources in the capital's healthcare organizations. Uroven' zhizni naselenija regionov Rossii = The standard of living of the population of the regions of Russia. 2021;17(2):243–51. doi: 10.19181/lsprr.2021.17.2.8 (in Russian).40.Aksenova E. I., Alexandrova O. A., Alikperova N. V., et al. The development of the corporate culture of medical organizations during the formation of medical tourism [Razvitie korporativnoj kul'tury medicinskih organizacij v period stanovlenija medicinskogo turizma]. Moscow: The State Budgetary Institution of the city of Moscow “Scientific Research Institute of Health Organization and Medical Management of the Department of Health of the City of Moscow”; 2022. 187 p. ISBN 978-5-907547-65-0. EDN LXJYLA (in Russian).41.Tsaranov K. N., Komolova O. A., Tarbastaev A. G. Training of heads of medical organizations: methods of social psychology. Vestnik Universiteta Pravitel'stva Moskvy = Bulletin of the University of the Government of Moscow. 2022;4(58):14–21. EDN LOHXRM (in Russian).