On the issue of determining notions “medical malpractice”, “yatrogeny” and “defect of medical care”: social legal aspects
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32687/0869-866X-2024-32-6-1343-1349Keywords:
medical error, iatrogenesis, medical care, defect, health protectionAbstract
The article considers social legal aspects of concepts of “medical error”, “iatrogenesis”, “defect of medical care” in view of absence of their clear definition and understanding in public and professional communities. The usage of these concepts is distinguished by chronological continuity that is conditioned by influence of approaches existed at different stages. On the basis of analysis of scientific publications and normative legal base their genesis and peculiarities of definition are demonstrated. The social aspects affecting their transformation were revealed. It is established that initially traditional understanding of possible shortcomings in medical work was formed as conscientious delusion of physician because of insufficiency of existing medical knowledge about certain health problems. The results of original empirical study demonstrated stability of this understanding in professional community of practicing physicians. However, in conditions of development of new model of national health care based on application of new diagnostic and treatment tools oriented to individual approach to patient and under effect of mediatization of health sphere traditional understanding of medical errors became limited that resulted in occurrence of concept of “medical care defect”. However, its application is limited due to ambiguity of interpretation because of absence of its definition in legal field. In this regard, the article emphasizes necessity of legal substantiation of relevant definitions due to increasing of both appeals from patients and the number of civil and criminal medical cases and proposes to introduce into legal circulation term “omission under provision of medical care”.
References
Shchepin V. O, Shishkin E. V. The analysis of mortality of population of able-bodied age because of external causes. Problemi socialnoi gigieni, zdravookhranenia i istorii meditsini = Problems of Social Hygiene, Public Health and History of Medicine. 2019;27(3):222–6 (in Russian).
Ivannikova E. V., Nikiforov S. A., Allenov A. M., et al. The problems of implementing strategies of prevention in The Russian Federation: The new considerations of old truths (publications review). Problemi socialnoi gigieni, zdravookhranenia i istorii meditsini = Problems of Social Hygiene, Public Health and History of Medicine. 2022;30(1):10–6 (in Russian).
Medvestnik. The results of 2023 for Russian healthcare. Available at: https://vspru.ru/association/rukovodstvo-vsp/zhulev/2024/01/itogi-2023-goda-dlia-rossiyskogo-zdravookhraneniia (accessed 29.07.2024) (in Russian).
Khokhlov A. L., Sychev D. A. The concept of patient-oriented medicine and pharmacy. Pacientoorientirovannaja medicina i farmacija = Patient-Oriented Medicine and Pharmacy. 2023;1(1):1–4 (In Russian).
Timurzieva A. B, Lindenbraten A. L. On certain issues of modern health care system development. Problemi socialnoi gigieni, zdravookhranenia i istorii meditsini = Problems of Social Hygiene, Public Health and History of Medicine. 2024;32(4):723–30 (in Russian).
The Constitution of the Russian Federation. Available at: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_28399/ (accessed 29.08.2024) (in Russian).
The Federal Law “On Compulsory Medical Insurance in the Russian Federation” from 29.11.2010 No 326-ФЗ. Available at: https://www.zakonrf.info/doc-32037907/ (accessed 30.08.2024) (in Russian).
The Law of the Russian Federation dated 07.02.1992 No. 2300-1 “On Consumer Rights Protection”. Available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_305/ (accessed 29.08.2024) (in Russian).
Federal Law of the Russian Federation No. 323-FZ dated November 21, 2011 “On the Basics of Public Health Protection in the Russian Federation”. Available at: https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_121895/ (accessed 29.08.2024) (in Russian).
Decree of the President of the Russian Federation “On the National Development Goals of the Russian Federation for the period up to 2030 and for the future up to 2036” dated 05/07/2024 No 309. Available at: http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/document/0001202405070015?index=1 (accessed 29.08.2024) (in Russian).
Tomilin O. O., Papasov A. V. Legal regulation of medical malpractice and iatrogenesis. Teorija i praktika obshhestvennogo razvitija = Theory and Practice of Social Development. 2023;4(182):151–4 (in Russian).
Mateykovich M. S., Mateykovich E. A. Legal Characteristics of Medical Errors and Minimizing the Risks of Their Commission. Zhurnal rossijskogo prava = Journal of Russian Law. 2021;25(9):61–77 (in Russian).
Malysheva J. J. The genesis of the concept of medical errors and its reflection in domestic and foreign criminal legislation. Humanitarian and Political-Legal Studies = Gumanitarnye i politiko-pravovye issledovanija. 2022;4(19):36–50 (in Russian).
Spasennikov B. A. About a medical error. Towards a Civil Society = Na puti k grazhdanskomu obshhestvu. 2024;2(54):18–20 (in Russian).
Pirogov N. I. Collected Works. Tom. II. Moscow: Medgiz; 1959. 624 p. (in Russian).
Davydovskij I. V. Medical errors. Soviet medicine = Sovetskaja medicina. 1941;(3):3–10 (in Russian).
Kassirskij I. A. About healing [O vrachevanii]. Moscow: Medicina; 1970 (in Russian).
Vermel I. G. Questions of the theory of forensic medical conclusion [Voprosy teorii sudebno-medicinskogo zakljuchenija]. Moscow: Medicina; 1979 (in Russian).
Ogarkov I. F. Medical offenses and criminal liability for them [Vrachebnye pravonarushenija i ugolovnaja otvetstvennost' za nih]. Leningrad: Medicina; 1966. 197 p. (in Russian).
Buromskij I. V., Klevno V. A., Pashinjan G. A. Forensic medical examination: Terms and concepts: Dictionary for lawyers and forensic experts [Sudebno-medicinskaja jekspertiza: Terminy i ponjatija: Slovar' dlja juristov i sudebno-medicinskih jekspertov]. Moscow: Norma; 2006 (in Russian).
Pashinjan G. A., Ivshin I. V. Professional crimes of medical workers against life and health [Professional'nye prestuplenija medicinskih rabotnikov protiv zhizni i zdorov'ja]. Moscow: Medicinskaja kniga; 2006 (in Russian).
Dvoretsky L. I. The journey to the land iatrogenesis. The Russian Archives of Internal Medicine = Arhiv vnutrennej mediciny. 2017;7(1):23–9 (in Russian).
Antipov V. V., Antipova S. I. Iatrogenesis as an inevitable phenomen in medicine of XXI century. Part I. From medical errors to iatrogenesis. Medical News = Meditsinskie novosti. 2017;(4):25–32 (in Russian).
Klevno V. A. Forensic medical examination: theoretical, procedural, organizational and methodological foundations [Sudebno-medicinskaja jekspertiza: teoreticheskie, processual'nye, organizacionnye i metodicheskie osnovy]. Moscow: GEOTAR-Media; 2012 (in Russian).
Starchenko A. A., Tarasova O. V., Saldueva O. V., Guzhenko M. D. The map of defects in medical care: a guide for medical professionals and experts on defects in medical care [Karta defektov medicinskoj pomoshhi: posobie dlja medicinskih rabotnikov i jekspertov po defektam okazanija medicinskoj pomoshhi]. Moscow, 2015 (in Russian).
Kolokolov A. V. “Medical error” or crime: where is the line? Herald of the Russian Law Academy = Vestnik Rossijskoj Pravovoj Akademii, 2021;(4):77–85 (in Russian).
Dmitriev I. V., Ignatova N. B., Abrosimov S. Yu. Some aspects of the problem of iatrogenism: past, present and future. Vestnik of Smolensk State Medical Academy = Vestnik Smolenskoj gosudarstvennoj medicinskoj akademii. 2023;22(3):216–30 (in Russian).
Review of appeals from citizens and organizations received by the Federal Service for Supervision of Healthcare, November, 2023. Available at: https://roszdravnadzor.gov.ru/i/upload/images/2023/12/22/1703249046.10773-1-1180686.doc (accessed 29.08.2024) (in Russian).
Sergeev Ju. D. Medical Law [Medicinskoe parvo]. In 3 Volumes. Moscow: GEOTAR-Media; 2008 (in Russian).
Downloads
Published
License
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of the first publication. The article simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work’s authorship and initial publication in this journal.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal’s published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
By submitting the article and accompanying files (hereinafter – the “Work”) the author (all the authors of the work, if it is created in co-authorship) agrees that he provides OAO Izdatelstvo Meditsina exclusive and perpetual right to use the work free of charge (exclusive, perpetual and royalty-free license) on the territory of Russia and foreign countries in the following ranges and volume:
- the publication of works on paper and / or electronic format, producing reprints of works, placing it on the Internet, both in the open and paid access, sending works metadata or full text indexing to various databases and repositories;
- reproduction of the work, i.e. the production of one or more copies of a work or part thereof in any material form, including in the form of audio or video recording. Recording on electronic media, including recording in computer memory, is also considered as a reproduction;
- distribution of works through sale or other alienation of its original or copies;
- public display of the work, that is, any demonstration of the original or copy of a work, either directly or on the screen using film, slide, television pictures or other technical means, as well as a demonstration of individual frames of an audiovisual work without concern for their order, either directly or with the help of technical means in a place open for free visits, or in a place where a significant number of individuals do not belong to the normal family, regardless of the perceived in the place of its display or elsewhere at the same time demonstrating product;
- import-export of the work or its parts for any lawful purpose (paid and gratis);
- translation or other processing of the works;
- bringing the work to the public so that anyone can access the work from any place and at any time of their choice;
- accommodation of works or parts thereof in a variety of collections of similar works;
- granting of rights in full or in part to third (physical and legal) persons at both the paid and free of charge.
Author’s items are not provided. The title is available by subscription.